Starch is removed from corn during the
production of alcohol. Since corn is comprised of approximately
two-thirds starch, the nutrients remaining in the byproduct,
distillers grains, are concentrated three-fold compared to corn
grain. Distillers grains typically contain 30-35% crude protein
(CP), 10-15% fat (oil), 40-45% neutral detergent fiber (NDF), and
0.8-0.9% phosphorus. Distillers byproducts are an excellent source
of protein and energy for feedlot cattle on high-grain diets and
also for cattle on high-forage diets. The inclusion of distillers
in beef diets appears favorable as current supply of wet and dry
distillers grains is plentiful and the supply trend is on the
rise.
Feedlot Diets
Distillers byproducts are normally available in two forms – dried
(DDG) and wet (WDB). In general, distillers byproducts are used as
either a primary protein source when fed at 6-15% of the dietary
dry matter (DM) or when fed at higher levels (greater than 15% of
dietary DM), distillers serve as an energy source replacing corn
grain. Other than the difference in dry matter content (wet
distillers – 35-45% DM; dried distillers – 90-95% DM), the
nutrient composition of the two distillers byproducts is similar.
Wet distillers byproducts are commonly fed at higher levels in
feedlot diets to supply both protein and energy. One advantage of
using WDB is the lower cost because energy cost associated with
drying distillers can be significantly reduced or eliminated. The
major disadvantage of using WDB is transportation costs associated
with the movement of a high-moisture feedstuff.
WDB Research
Table 1 provides a summary of 11 experiments in which WDB was
compared to corn as an energy source for finishing cattle. Wet
distillers replaced varying amounts of corn (2.6% to 50% of the
diet). The data in Table 1 were summarized into three situations:
-
Control diet based on dry rolled
corn
-
WDB replaced corn at a low level in
the diet (12.6% to 28%)
-
WDB replaced corn in the diet at 30%
to 50% of dietary DM
At the low level (average 17.4%) of
WDB feeding, the energy value was 152% that of corn. At the high
level of feeding, the value decreased to 136% the value of corn.
From these data, the value of WDB was calculated as 124% the value
of corn when fed between 17.4% and 40% of the diet. The change in
relative feeding values as WDB increases in the diet is thought to
be due to:
-
The lower amount of WDB fed (up to
17.4%) supplied nutrients, such as protein, that may be of value
to feedlot cattle, but more importantly reduced acidosis that
occurred in the control diet. The WDB contains protein and fat,
which supply energy to feedlot cattle, but it does not contain
starch that predisposes cattle to acidosis when fed in large
amounts.
-
The fiber (hull) in WDB is highly
digestible, yet adds fiber to the diet, which helps reduce
acidosis. Consequently, the very high value of WDB (152%) at the
low level feeding is probably due to factors other than the
strict energy value of WDB.
Feedlot trials determined the value of
feeding WDB at levels above 17.4% of the diet is 124% the value of
corn. The feeding value of WDB when fed above 17.4% of the diet is
probably due to the high fat and high bypass protein WDB. Fat has
about three times the energy value of starch for cattle, and
bypass protein provides about 30% more energy than starch. By
calculating the theoretical energy value based on the bypass
protein and fat contents, the energy value of WDB is estimated at
120% of the value of corn, which is similar to the value obtained
from feeding trials.
Acidosis Connection
Typical feedlot diets are high in starch due to the large amount
of corn fed (~85% of the diet is corn). Starch from corn is
rapidly fermented to organic acids by rumen microorganisms. An
overproduction of organic acids causes acidosis, resulting in
reduced feed intake and reduced gains. Distillers byproducts have
essentially all of the starch removed leaving protein, highly
digestible fiber, and fat. Due to very little to no starch
content, the feeding of distillers byproducts appears to reduce
acidosis and enhance feed efficiency in feedlot diets.
High-Forage Diets
Distillers byproducts also provide feeding value to cattle fed
high-forage diets, namely stockers, replacement heifers, and brood
cows, especially during winter when forages are typically low in
protein and phosphorus needs rise due to reproductive stage of
brood cows. The use of distillers byproducts with high-forage
diets is complementary as forage protein is typically highly
degraded in the rumen, while distillers byproducts provide an
excellent source of undegraded protein. Distillers byproducts are
an economical source of protein. An added plus is the minimal
starch content of distillers byproducts does not depress fiber
digestion.
Conclusion
The higher feeding value for distillers byproducts in feedlot
diets is primarily due to the protein and energy content of
distillers byproducts, and the reduction in incidences of acidosis
due to very little starch in distillers byproducts. Distillers
byproducts have 120% to 150% of the energy value of dry rolled
corn in feedlot finishing diets. Reduction in acidosis is likely
responsible for the higher apparent values and may be the primary
advantage of using distillers byproducts in feedlot diets. Based
on limited available data, the economic value of WDB varies as the
level fed in the feedlot diet changes. The precise relationship
between level of distillers byproduct in the feedlot diet and both
the feeding value and economic value remains elusive. The high
rumen undegradable protein content of distillers byproducts makes
it an excellent protein source for cattle on high-forage diets and
offers economic advantages.
The preceding article was adapted from
Dr. Klopfenstein’s article “Feeding Distillers Grains to
Ruminants,” in the Proceedings from the Third National Symposium
on Alternative Feeds for Livestock and Poultry, November 4-5,
2003, pgs 53-64.
For More Information
Call TOLL FREE (1-866-666-7626)
Please
include the following information with your e-mail questions:
Name,
Address, City, State, Zip Code, and Telephone Phone Number.
E-mail
AN_BeefHelp@admworld.com